Finding the Right Clarifying Shampoo for Your Hair
I spent three months, on a mission to test some of the most popular clarifying shampoos available today. My goal was simple: to give you honest, detailed reviews so you can understand what these products actually do, what they’re designed for, and whether they’re truly effective.
Through the years, I’ve recommended specific clarifying shampoos to my community, but the industry and market keep changing. Some favorites have been discontinued, others reformulated, and a few fell out of my rotation because I didn’t feel confident they were safe for silver hair. That prompted me to take a fresh look at what’s currently available.
I started paying attention to what my favorite curly-haired friends and members of the silver hair community were using for clarification. I wanted to test these products myself to see what actually works and what would be safe and effective for those of us with silver hair.
Disclosure: The product links in this post may be affiliate links. As an Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases, at no additional cost to you. Read my Terms and Conditions Page to learn more.
Click any product name I mention or the photo and the link will take you to the product page for purchase.
Understanding Clarifying vs. Chelating
Before we dive into the product reviews, let’s clear up some confusion about clarifying and chelating – because they’re not the same thing, though they often work together.
Chelating ingredients bind to minerals in your hair. These minerals come from hard water, well water, chlorine, and similar sources. They’re not easy to remove with basic clarifying ingredients alone. Chelating ingredients can be present in regular shampoos (where they help stabilize the formula), but that doesn’t necessarily mean the shampoo will chelate your hair effectively.
I have a full video on chelating, check it out if you want to learn more.
Clarifying shampoos are designed to remove buildup – whether that’s from products, silicones, waxes, or minerals, depending on the formulation and whether chelating ingredients are included at effective concentrations.
Here’s the key: All clarifying shampoo clarifies, but not all clarifying shampoo chelates. And while all chelating shampoo can clarify, it doesn’t have to be marketed as a clarifying shampoo to do the job.
I know this sounds confusing, but here’s what matters: If you buy a product designed for your specific needs and it claims to do what you’re looking for, that’s what you need to focus on.
Throughout this post, when I mention clarifying ingredients, I’m referring to ingredients that remove product buildup from your hair care routine. When I mention chelating ingredients, I’m talking about ingredients that remove minerals, hard water deposits, well water residue, and chlorine.
My Testing Process
For each product, I evaluated several key factors:
- What it was designed to accomplish,
- The price point,
- Key active ingredients,
- How well it lathered,
- The scent,
- Whether it felt stripping or not,
- Overall performance on my hair.
To keep the testing fair, I used the same deep conditioner after each clarifying session.
One important note: When you clarify your hair, always follow up with a moisturizing conditioner or deep conditioner to restore the moisture that clarifying can strip away.
Pro Tip: If you need to use purple products for permanent yellowing, clarify first and follow with a toning moisturizing conditioner, rather than using drying purple shampoos.
Now, let’s get into the reviews.
If you prefer my videos you can check out the corresponding video over on YouTube:
Aveeno Apple Cider Vinegar Clarifying and Shine Shampoo
SULFATE-FREE
Designed for: Scalp care, removing oil and product buildup
Price: Approximately $6.50 per bottle
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium C 14-16 Olefin Sulfonate (clarifying)
- Vinegar
- Sodium citrate (chelating)
- Citric Acid (chelating)
Performance: This shampoo created a very foamy lather but required two washes due to a filmy feeling left by the oatmeal content. The synthetic, perfumey scent was overpowering and clingy, lingering even after rinsing. While it didn’t initially feel stripping, the vinegar actually did dry out the hair significantly. For those with low porosity hair, the vinegar can be problematic as it closes the cuticle even further, defeating the purpose of clarifying. This resulted in a ruined wash day that required rewashing the next day.
Verdict: Two thumbs down
A Note About Vinegar and Hair Porosity:
Low Porosity Hair: The cuticle is already flat and laid down with very few chips and minimal raising. Since vinegar is more acidic than hair’s natural pH, it closes the cuticle down even further. This defeats the purpose of clarifying because you’re not getting the slight lift needed to remove buildup from underneath the cuticle – instead, it’s slamming the cuticle shut.
High Porosity Hair: Vinegar works well because it cleanses the cuticle and then closes it back up, which is beneficial for coarse or higher porosity hair types.
Bumble and Bumble Sunday Clarifying Shampoo
Designed for: Scalp care, removing oil and product buildup
Price: Approximately $36 for 8.5 ounces
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium Laureth Sulfate (clarifying)
- Tetrasodium EDTA (chelating)
Performance: This product delivered excellent suds with just one wash needed. The light, clean scent dissipated quickly, which was appreciated. It left hair feeling squeaky clean without being stripped, though there was some expected frizziness after clarifying. Hair felt genuinely clean and in good condition after use, with only minimal dryness.
Verdict: Two thumbs up – a quality product that justifies why people love it (though not suitable for those avoiding sulfates).
Curlsmith Curl Reset Detox Shampoo
SULFATE-FREE
CHELATING
Designed for: Scalp care, clarifying buildup, and removing minerals
Price: Approximately $28 for 8 ounces
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium C 14-16 Olefin Sulfonate (clarifying)
- Vinegar
- Sodium Gluconate (chelating)
- Phytic Acid (chelating)
Performance: The shampoo suds well but contains unexpected scrubbing beads that can irritate sensitive or dry scalps. The peppermint-based scent is somewhat odd. It proved very stripping, leaving hair feeling dry even before rinsing was complete. However, it effectively removed minerals and noticeably brightened silver hair, creating a silver brightening effect. Despite feeling dry during the wash, hair ended up with silky, good curls afterward, though with some frizziness.
Verdict: Two thumbs up with caveats – highly effective for mineral removal and brightening, but best for those who can tolerate the beads, scent, and vinegar content.
Ion Purify Hard Water Shampoo
SULFATE-FREE
CHELATING
Designed for: Removing buildup from products, iron, well water, hard water; for oily hair types; gentle enough for daily use
Price: Approximately $10 for 10 ounces (available at Sally Beauty)
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium C 14-16 Olefin Sulfonate (clarifying)
- Disodium EDTA (chelating)
Performance: This shampoo suds perfectly and works well overall. It has a light but perfumey scent. While marketed for daily use, the multiple surfactants make it quite clarifying, so it’s best used sparingly unless you have very oily hair. It’s not stripping per se, but it is very thorough and requires following up with a deep conditioner. Regular use can lead to dryness, so it’s best used only occasionally.
Verdict: Good clarifying shampoo but requires careful use to avoid drying out hair.
Malibu C Undo Goo
SULFATE-FREE
Designed for: Product buildup and oily scalp (not chelating, not designed for hard water)
Price: Approximately $18 for 9 ounces
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium C 14-16 Olefin Sulfonate (clarifying)
- Disodium EDTA (chelating)
Performance: This shampoo suds very well and typically requires two washes – the first to break up buildup, the second to carry it away. It has a light, clean citrus scent. It can be stripping if used too frequently without following with deep conditioner. Hair consistently feels and looks good after use.
Verdict: Solid clarifying option for buildup and oily hair and scalp.
Good Example: this product contains a chelating agent, but is not designed for use as a chelating shampoo. (verified with Malibu C)
The Ordinary Sulphate 4% Cleanser for Body and Hair
FRAGRANCE-FREE
CHELATING
Designed for: Thorough cleansing and reset
Price: Approximately $9 for 8 ounces
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium Laureth Sulfate (clarifying)
- Phytic Acid (chelating)
- Trisodium Ethylenediamine Disuccinate (chelating)
Performance: This product suds great and acts like a normal shampoo. It’s specifically formulated at 4% sulfate concentration – enough to be effective without being excessive. Hair consistently feels and looks good after use, with a squeaky clean feel but without being stripped.
Works beautifully when paired with the matching conditioner or blended with QuickSilverHair clay clarifying mask. This is my go-to product for hitting the complete reset button, especially after testing multiple products or when needing everything thoroughly removed from my hair.
Verdict: Two thumbs up – simple, fragrance-free, and highly recommended, especially for those with fragrance allergies.
Enjoy both the QuickSilverHair Clay and Squalane Oil
- Get the benefits of clarifying and hitting reset for your silver and curls with a clay mask.
- Use the clay once or twice a month to return your hair to all its glory.
- The 100% Clear and Pure Squalane oil is perfect for smoothing frizz, scrunching out the crunch, and protecting your hair from the environment.
Ouidad Water Works Clarifying Shampoo
CHELATING
Designed for: Curly hair (though suitable for silver straight hair too); chelating and clarifying for all forms of buildup
Price: Approximately $18 for 8.5 ounces
Key Ingredients:
- Ammonium Laureth Sulfate, (clarifying)
- Sodium Laureth Sulfate, (clarifying)
- Along with five other surfactants
- Disodium EDTA (chelating)
Performance: The shampoo is light but foams nicely with only one wash needed. The scent is light and synthetic but much less bothersome than many other Ouidad products. It delivers a squeaky clean feel without being overly stripped, though the number of cleansing agents may be excessive. Hair felt soft and fluffy with some frizziness and less-than-ideal curls. The scalp became itchy as the day progressed, likely due to excess surfactants. While it’s a good clarifying shampoo, it contains way too many surfactants, in my opinion.
Verdict: Good for severe buildup situations, but there are better products in this lineup. May work well for curly girls who use several products and have significant buildup.
Paul Mitchell Clarifying Shampoo 2

CHELATING
Designed for: Oily hair and clarifying buildup
Price: Approximately $17.50 for 16.9 ounces
Key Ingredients:
- Sodium Lauryl Sulfate, (clarifying)
- Cocamidopropyl Betaine,
- Tetrasodium EDTA (chelating)
Performance: This shampoo suds really well on the second wash (typical for Paul Mitchell products). It has a light lemon scent that’s not overpowering and fades throughout the day. After the second shampoo, it delivers a squeaky clean feel. Silver hair looked bright, shiny, and genuinely clean – a beautiful result. Most surprisingly, curls rebounded and looked better than with any other product in the lineup, resulting in one of my best hair days in a long time. Even better, I was able to repeat the results with multiple uses.
Verdict: Outstanding performance – out of all the washdays this was my favorite, my hair felt and looked incredible.
If you need chlorine removal try Paul Mitchell Shampoo Three
In The End:
I understand that clarifying and chelating can feel confusing, but the truth is, if you choose a product designed to do the specific job you need it to do, it will likely accomplish that task effectively.
While the products I tested varied in their specific purposes and formulations, nearly all of them did successfully clarify my hair – with the exception of the Aveeno shampoo, which I didn’t feel clarified effectively at all.
My hope is that this comprehensive review gives you more options when shopping for clarifying products. I know not everyone has access to the same products, and many of you struggle to find clarifying shampoos that work well for your specific hair type. Hopefully, somewhere in this lineup, there’s a product that will be the right fit for you.
I hope you found this post educational and helpful.
Thank you for reading. Please feel free to share.
As always it is about so much more than the hair.
§
Next Suggested Post
*Affiliate Links:
QuickSilverHair is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Some of the links on this site are affiliate links to Amazon.com. I earn money as an Amazon Associate from qualifying purchases.
QuickSilverHair is an affiliate with several brands, I earn a small percentage from any qualifying purchases, at no additional cost to you.
© Copyright disclaimer: All content is written by Joli A. Campbell or Guests, that content belongs to QuickSilverHair or the respected author. All Images in this blog belong to the women in the picture, myself, or were used with purchase or commercial permissions. I have used their images and names with their permission. Please do not copy or redistribute anything from this site without further permission. Thank you.
QuickSilverHair.com content disclaimer: content is provided for general information purposes and should not be considered medical advice. Product information is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The hair care content is also for educational use, I am not a hair care professional or dermatologist, please be careful with your hair and skin. If you have any hesitations or concerns speak to your doctor or hair care professional for their support before using any information you find on this site. Be well.
For full Affiliate and Copyright Details Please Read My Terms & Conditions Page